Initially a conscientious objector from the Tennessee hills, Alvin C. York was drafted after America’s entry into World War I and assigned to the 328th Infantry Regiment of the 82d Division, the “All Americans.” PVT York, a devout Christian, told his commander, CPT E. C. B. Danforth, that he would bear arms against the enemy—but did not believe in killing. Recognizing PVT York as a good Soldier and potential leader but unable to sway him from his convictions, CPT Danforth consulted his battalion commander, MAJ George E. Buxton, on how to handle the situation. MAJ Buxton, a religious man with excellent knowledge of the Bible, had CPT Danforth bring PVT York to him. The major and PVT York talked at length about the Scriptures, God’s teachings, about right and wrong, and just wars. Then MAJ Buxton sent PVT York home on leave to ponder and pray over the dilemma. The battalion commander had promised to release York from the Army if he decided that he could not serve his country without sacrificing his integrity. After two weeks of reflection and soul-searching, PVT York returned to his unit. He had reconciled his personal values with those of the Army. PVT York’s decision would have great consequences for both himself and his unit. In the morning hours of 8 October 1918 in France’s Argonne Forest, now CPL York, after winning his stripes during combat in the Lorraine, would demonstrate the character and heroism that would become part of American military history. CPL York’s battalion was moving across a valley to seize a German-held rail point when a German infantry battalion, hidden on a wooded ridge overlooking the valley, opened with machine gun fire. The Americans sought cover and the attack stalled. CPL York’s platoon, reduced to 16 men, was sent to flank the enemy guns. They advanced through the woods, surprising a group of some 25 Germans. The shocked enemy troops offered only token resistance as several hidden machine guns swept the clearing with fire. The Germans immediately dropped to the ground unharmed, while nine Americans, including the platoon leader and two other corporals, fell from the hail of bullets. CPL York was the only unwounded American leader remaining. CPL York found his platoon trapped and under fire within 25 yards of enemy machine gun pits. Instead of panicking, he began firing into the nearest enemy position, aware that the Germans would have to expose themselves to aim at him. An expert marksman, CPL York was able to hit every enemy who lifted his head over the parapet. After CPL York shot more than a dozen, six Germans decided to charge with fixed bayonets. As the Germans ran toward him, CPL York, drawing on the instincts of a Tennessee hunter, shot the last man in the German group first, so the others would not know that they were under fire. York then shot all the assaulting Germans, moving his fire up to the front of the column. Finally, he again turned his attention to the machine gun pits. In between shots, he called at the Germans to surrender. Although it seemed ludicrous for a lone Soldier to call on a well-entrenched enemy to surrender, the opposing German battalion commander, who had seen over 20 of his Soldiers killed, advanced and offered to surrender to CPL York if he ceased firing. CPL York faced a daunting task. His platoon, with merely seven unwounded Soldiers, was isolated behind enemy lines with several dozen prisoners. When one American reminded York that the platoon’s predicament was hopeless, he told him to be quiet. CPL York soon moved the prisoners and his platoon toward American lines, encountering other German positions also forcing their surrender. By the time the platoon reached the edge of the valley they left just a few hours before, the hill was clear of all German machine guns. The suppressive fires on the Americans substantially reduced, the advance could continue. CPL York returned to American lines with 132 prisoners and 35 German machine guns out of action. After delivering the prisoners, he returned to his unit. U.S. Intelligence officers later questioned the prisoners to learn that one determined American Soldier, armed with only a rifle and pistol, had defeated an entire German battalion. For his heroic actions, CPL York was promoted to sergeant and awarded the Medal of Honor. His character, physical courage, competence, and leadership enabled him to destroy the morale and effectiveness of an entire enemy infantry battalion.